⋙ Libro Rose Daughter Robin Mckinley Books

Rose Daughter Robin Mckinley Books

Download As PDF : Rose Daughter Robin Mckinley Books

Rose Daughter Robin Mckinley Books

I will preface by saying two things: First that I have not read Beauty, though I'm not sure why I haven't; somehow I simply never did. So I came to this with nothing to compare it to except all the many other retellings of the tale I have read, so perhaps Beauty is better or perhaps it is only different and perhaps also nostalgic. And second I will say, I have been a fan of Robin McKinley since I was a little girl, drinking down the story of the Blue Sword, and then the Hero and the Crown, and I have always loved these stories in a way that is delighted and yet also a bit melancholy. It is a skill of the author, to write a story that makes your whole heart swell right along with her characters', and then when the story is over you are left feeling as if you are saying farewell to a friend who became very dear in a very brief time.
So perhaps this is not the tale for you, and certainly it is not always the tale for me even, for sometimes to feel melancholy is very terrible. But it is a very good story, in its way. A charming and lovely one.
I will be honest, for all that I half wish to just yell that everyone should read this, and give a nice little list of pros and cons, as they stood out to me:
Pros
Beauty is quite an excellent version of her character. She is strong in heart and mind, and though her name is Beauty for her physical beauty, it seems to apply more to her inner beauty, for her most prominent character trait is probably that she is kind. But it doesn't feel forced or cheesy or cliche, and she isn't kind in the face of anything ridiculous. She is patient, but she's not a wimp or a wilting damsel.
The Beast is interesting. I liked how he became a beast, who he was before, and his casual kindness.
This is a book of much kindness, triumphing over evil, which I personally think is splendid.
The relationship between Beauty and her sisters is nice. It's well-developed, the sisters are distinct characters, who don't always get along but in a realistic way. Their character development is perhaps abrupt, but it didn't feel that way, or if it does it feels like it is abrupt because it ought to be. It makes sense, and they don't become different people entirely--they are simply different.
There are others but I'm terrible at making a bullet point, so I'll summarize the pros as: the characters are generally good, the setting is elaborate without taking so long to decide everything as to make you stop caring, the repeated themes and similar are very nice, and overall it's just an enjoyable read.

Cons
There are only three big cons I can think of. First off, what feels most important to me, is the Beast himself. He has many excellent moments, but he never quite develops into a character. He is always the Beast and, even when theoretically developed, he just falls a bit flat, which draws from my second major con:
Underexplaining. The more I think about the story, the more questions I come up with. Some of it is simply the underexplaining of a fairy tale, and didn't bother to much. But even those bother you, once you've (metaphorically or otherwise) put the book down. I won't actually ask the questions, because they're spoilers, but while key things are explained--some key things aren't. Some very important things are--left up to interpretation I guess? It's odd, mostly. And some of them aren't explained but you definitely know the truth of them by the end--but at the same time, you (or at least I) would have liked then expanded upon.
Finally, the fairytale cliche: instalove. The romance between Beauty and the Beast is...unconvincing. It's not distracting, or terrible, but it's, well. It's instalove. It has to be said.

But I'm giving it five stars. Because despite everything, reading it was a delight.


Tags : Amazon.com: Rose Daughter (9780441005833): Robin Mckinley: Books,Robin Mckinley,Rose Daughter,Ace,0441005837,Romance - General,Fairy tales,Fairy tales.,Folklore - France,Folklore;France.,Children: Young Adult (Gr. 7-9),Fairy Tales & Folklore - General,Folk Tales Mythology Fables (Young Adult),Juvenile Fiction,Juvenile Grades 7-9 Ages 12-14,MASS MARKET,Romance,TEEN'S FICTION FANTASY,TEEN'S FOLK TALES MYTHOLOGY FAIRY TALES,YOUNG ADULT FICTION,YOUNG ADULT FICTION Fairy Tales & Folklore General,YOUNG ADULT FICTION Fantasy General,YOUNG ADULT FICTION Romance General,Young Adult FictionFantasy - General,Young Adult FictionRomance - General,fairytale;fairy tale retelling;beauty and the beast;fantasy;fantasy books;books for 13 year old girls;books for 12 year old girls;tween books for girls ages 11-14;teen fiction books;romance books;teen romance books;books for 12 year old boys;teen books for boys;books for 14 year old girls;books for 14 year old boys;teen books;young adult books;books for teens;teen girl books;ya books;young adult;books for teen girls;teen boy books;teen books for girls;books for teen boys;fantasy novels,fantasy; fairy tale retelling; fantasy books; romance books; teen romance books; teen fiction books; young adult fantasy books; fantasy books for teens; fairytale; beauty and the beast; teen books; young adult books; books for teens; books for 13 year old girls; books for 12 year old girls; tween books for girls ages 11-14; ya books; teen books for girls; books for teen girls; young adult; books for 12 year old boys; books for teen boys; books for 13 year old boys; teen girl books; teen books for boys; teen boy books,Fairy Tales & Folklore - General,YOUNG ADULT FICTION Fairy Tales & Folklore General,YOUNG ADULT FICTION Fantasy General,YOUNG ADULT FICTION Romance General,Young Adult FictionFantasy - General,Young Adult FictionRomance - General,Folk Tales Mythology Fables (Young Adult),YOUNG ADULT FICTION,Children: Young Adult (Gr. 7-9),Romance

Rose Daughter Robin Mckinley Books Reviews

It was an interesting idea.... but the book itself is unfulfilling....

I didn't really read enough into this to know what it was. I kind of thought it would be a continuation of her book "Beauty" which was the best and most beautiful version of "Beauty and the Beast" that I've ever read, but it was simply a different version. McKinley talks about how this is the version that she wanted to write, but she couldn't get it "right" and wouldn't accept it until this one..... I think it's still a failure.

It might just be because I'm comparing it to the beauty of "Beauty", but even without her previous version, I wouldn't like this one. The story is not well thought out (or maybe she just overthought it for too many years). It is very confusing and doesn't have a very good flow. It just seems like a lot of information was omitted and the information that was given doesn't always match up. Also the ending was just rushed and seemed like a bunch of nonsense.

After putting the book down for a while, I did realize that there were some very interesting aspects of this version of the story and had it not felt so rushed and mottled, it might have been a good story.

I strongly think she just spent too long mulling over this idea and by the time she wrote it down, she was able to read it and fill in the missing bits on her own. Therefore, she had no idea how this would read for someone who didn't have the full concept in their head.... I don't know if that made sense.... but yeah.
I prefer Robin McKinley's Beauty a Retelling. The main character in Rose Daughter seems weak, and while the entire drama takes 7 months in real time, the main character only spends a week with the Beast. One week is not enough time to get to know someone enough to want to marry them. It was fun to read, but in the end it was too fantastic to really suspend my disbelief; I couldn't lose myself in the book because I couldn't relate to the constant over-the-top magic surrounding everyone and everything.
My favourite fairy-tale of all-time is Cindrella, but The Beauty and the Beast is a very close second and I simply adore what McKinley did with the classic story. She put her own twist to it in a magical way that simply grabbed my attention and made it very, very difficult for me to put the book down late at night. Rose Daughter both is and isn't your typical Beauty and the Beast story and I simply loved reading it.

I admit, it was slow at times, but slow was just the thing I needed at the moment. It was just the right pace for me and I while some readers are not happy with the way McKinley decided to dot the i with this one, I have to say that I'm one of those readers who like that ending. I like that it's different and I liked that I didn't predict it right from the start.

I'm not saying that this book is perfect, because it isn't, but it was damn good and I didn't care in the slightest about the fact that Beauty and Beast didn't get to really interact before there was love; I didn't care that some of it made little sense (e.g. flowers blooming in less than 7 days when at the beginning they were dying); I didn't care that some questions I had, were left unanswered, because all that matters, is that I had a real good time reading and I would gladly read more of McKinley's books when I get the chance.
I will preface by saying two things First that I have not read Beauty, though I'm not sure why I haven't; somehow I simply never did. So I came to this with nothing to compare it to except all the many other retellings of the tale I have read, so perhaps Beauty is better or perhaps it is only different and perhaps also nostalgic. And second I will say, I have been a fan of Robin McKinley since I was a little girl, drinking down the story of the Blue Sword, and then the Hero and the Crown, and I have always loved these stories in a way that is delighted and yet also a bit melancholy. It is a skill of the author, to write a story that makes your whole heart swell right along with her characters', and then when the story is over you are left feeling as if you are saying farewell to a friend who became very dear in a very brief time.
So perhaps this is not the tale for you, and certainly it is not always the tale for me even, for sometimes to feel melancholy is very terrible. But it is a very good story, in its way. A charming and lovely one.
I will be honest, for all that I half wish to just yell that everyone should read this, and give a nice little list of pros and cons, as they stood out to me
Pros
Beauty is quite an excellent version of her character. She is strong in heart and mind, and though her name is Beauty for her physical beauty, it seems to apply more to her inner beauty, for her most prominent character trait is probably that she is kind. But it doesn't feel forced or cheesy or cliche, and she isn't kind in the face of anything ridiculous. She is patient, but she's not a wimp or a wilting damsel.
The Beast is interesting. I liked how he became a beast, who he was before, and his casual kindness.
This is a book of much kindness, triumphing over evil, which I personally think is splendid.
The relationship between Beauty and her sisters is nice. It's well-developed, the sisters are distinct characters, who don't always get along but in a realistic way. Their character development is perhaps abrupt, but it didn't feel that way, or if it does it feels like it is abrupt because it ought to be. It makes sense, and they don't become different people entirely--they are simply different.
There are others but I'm terrible at making a bullet point, so I'll summarize the pros as the characters are generally good, the setting is elaborate without taking so long to decide everything as to make you stop caring, the repeated themes and similar are very nice, and overall it's just an enjoyable read.

Cons
There are only three big cons I can think of. First off, what feels most important to me, is the Beast himself. He has many excellent moments, but he never quite develops into a character. He is always the Beast and, even when theoretically developed, he just falls a bit flat, which draws from my second major con
Underexplaining. The more I think about the story, the more questions I come up with. Some of it is simply the underexplaining of a fairy tale, and didn't bother to much. But even those bother you, once you've (metaphorically or otherwise) put the book down. I won't actually ask the questions, because they're spoilers, but while key things are explained--some key things aren't. Some very important things are--left up to interpretation I guess? It's odd, mostly. And some of them aren't explained but you definitely know the truth of them by the end--but at the same time, you (or at least I) would have liked then expanded upon.
Finally, the fairytale cliche instalove. The romance between Beauty and the Beast is...unconvincing. It's not distracting, or terrible, but it's, well. It's instalove. It has to be said.

But I'm giving it five stars. Because despite everything, reading it was a delight.